Title screens and some character portraits! (More stuff)

[Zattersmox 4]

Here i've got two title screens and a (very) early render of a character's conversation portrait. I use daz and cararra for different renders.

Which of the two title screens looks better? I like them both but I can only use one, obviously. Also, any ideas on how to improve on the rat's render? (Lighting, shading, etc.)

 

(Edit: There's more stuff. Not sure which style I should stay with.)

Edited June 5, 2015 by Zattersmox

[Tsarmina 2,612]

I think the second one is better He looks less...elastic. And it helps him fit into the darker background as a kind of setting.

[Zattersmox 4]

I think the second one is better He looks less...elastic. And it helps him fit into the darker background as a kind of setting.

Thanks =p

I wasn't sure whether to go with the more toon-like one, or something more realistic. Considering the way the game itself is portayed I wanted to get some outside opinions.

[Valvatoras 1]

I too prefer the ones that look more like cartoons.  They seem more realistic.
 

[Zattersmox 4]

I too prefer the ones that look more like cartoons.  They seem more realistic.

 

I'm not sure I understand that, but thanks for the feedback ^~^