Which kind of game would you prefer ? NEED FEEDBACKS PLEASE;

[Dear_Elise 36]

Greetings everyone !

 

 

I am currently facing a hard decision .

I have too storyline I really appreaciate and I would like to make a game out of both of them however , I really cannot which one to start with .

 

This way , I would like you to tell me which one would you prefer :

 

The first one , it involves several characters (around 15) , this will be a visual novel , survival , sci-fi , mystery , point and click game .

In this game , people will die and you will have to discover who is the murderer behind each crime in order to execute them to gain something and discover what has mysteriously happened to them . The storyline will have twists and be rather psychological .

There will be a point and click interface , you will be able to interact which characters and get to know their backstory .

 

The second , has fewer characters (around 4) , this will be a 2D cute , fantasist , mystery and magic game .

In this game , you will have to discover a mystery involving around the main character when she finds out that her crush mysteriously disappears and that people around seem to freeze without even noticing it .

There will be many mini games but it will be mainly about sinking for specific items to go through the storyline which will lead to several endings .

 

 

There are two pictures : the two first pictures shows most of the characters ( I haven't drawn all of them yet) from the first (survival) game idea and the second picture shows an exemple of point and click interface .

 

There two last pictures show two maps from the second (cute) game .

Edited February 6, 2017 by Wisteria D.L

[lonequeso 1,921]

The environments are really good. They have visual novel written all over them. I like the first idea more. It's like if "Clue" was a visual novel. I love that game so I'm a bit biased.

[+ Takeo212 1,079]

Do both!

 

Honestly, I've seen you work on your mystery game so I highly recommend you stick to that for now.

Your second game doesn't have to be canceled. Just delayed.

 

Don't start making any new games during production. You'll end up in a continuous loop that; everytime you make a game, a new idea will pop up and you will want to do that instead. Don't do that!

 

Make notes for your second game, so after you finish your mystery game, you can make that one next You already have so many lovely characters drawn for it and background sceneries, so you may as well continue it

[Tsarmina 2,612]

I really like the idea of the second game >< And it looks super adorable. I'm a sucker for stuff like that. Seriously though, I know how much work you've done on your other game so I think it'd be great to see that come out too